Don’t learn on cheap crap
So yesterday, as I was out and about shopping with my roomie, and erstwhile MG.com member, Jenny at Sam’s Club, we passed the section where they have the cheap instruments. Now, I don’t mean cheap like Epiphone or Squier. I mean, stuff that makes those brands look like top of the line gear. She of course, being possessed of perfect pitch and just a touch of OCD has to tune them. It was…amusing to watch, although I think there are some kids with a rather expanded vocabulary that their parents would have rather they not learned.
We got to talking about cheap instruments, and my first guitar, a really dirt-cheap Ibanez, and what happens with them. (Understand that even my Ibanez was way better than what we’re talking about here.) I honestly think, and I’m saying this as a beginner, that a crappy instrument is the worst thing a beginner can have. While Jenny can speak of keyboards and other things, I can tell you that a really cheap guitar makes you hate playing. You can’t keep it in tune. I don’t mean for a couple of days. I mean while you’re playing the damned thing. The frets are crap, to the point where you can’t even play an open string, much less a fretted one without the buzz from hell. They don’t sound right. They don’t feel right.
Let’s understand something, unless you’re a prodigy, learning to play something like a guitar is hard at first. There’s a lot of stuff that just takes time before it makes sense. I still have some problems with smooth chord changes. But even beyond that, dealing with different keys, odd chords, different tunings, it’s all quite intimidating. I’m luckier than most, I have a friggin’ Mozart in the house I can ask about. What about the kid or the adult who’s the only one in the house who wants to play? If they have some cheap piece of crap, they’re screwed. I tried to learn guitar before, when I was 12. The only thing I could afford was a cheap piece of crap. Guess what happened. Yep. Gave it up, and decided that I just wasn’t a person who could do that. It took me 25 years to get over that.
When I had that Ibanez, it wasn’t bad, but it could take a while to tune, and it just never stayed in tune. It also never felt right, and while I was learning, I wasn’t really enjoying. But a few weeks after I got it, I get a call from Jenny who told me that at the Musician’s Friend warehouse, here in Kansas City, there was a brand new Gibson Les Paul for under $600. Now, for those of you who know Gibson, this is, essentially free for a new one. The difference was amazing. At the time, I thought it was due to the neck being .8mm wider. Now I realize it was just the difference between a good instrument that had a lower price, and a cheap one. It’s dead easy to tune, only goes out of tune for weather reasons, plays easier, and doesn’t have a dozen annoying quirks that make me worry about the guitar. I don’t think I’d be half as far along as I am if I’d stuck with the Ibanez. (Note, this is not saying all Ibanez’s are crap. But that particular model? That one is crap.
When my son showed an interest in learning guitar, I let him play with the Ibanez, and he hated it. He just couldn’t get it in tune. So, I got him a used Epiphone SG for like $200, and again, the difference was amazing. He loves that new one, not just because it’s just like the one Allison Robertson plays in “Fall Behind Me” (Which doesn’t suck. He liked that a lot when he saw The Donnas live), but as he said, “It’s nicer to play”. It’s nice enough that he wants to get into Jazz band in school so he can really learn how to play. A complete attitude change, and all because his instrument doesn’t suck.
So here’s my advice, and I imagine the other folks will chime in on this in the comments. If you have a kid, a friend, whatever who’s wanting to learn guitar, don’t just buy them one, unless you really know what you’re doing, i.e., you play, and have played for a few years. If you aren’t a player, but you know know someone who is, go down to a local music store, and have them show you some gear that would be good for a beginner. If you don’t know a player, talk to the folks that work at the store. Yes, they do indeed want to sell you something, but most of them are players themselves, so you should be able to get good advice, especially if you’re talking about a smaller non-chain store. Even if you’re talking name brand, you can get a solid guitar for no more than $600, and if you’re willing to go used, you can get a great guitar for that. Instead of giving them the instrument, take them to the music store, and let them pick out the one they want in the correct price range. (Note, while I’m not saying get them a cheap POS, I’m also not saying get them a $50,000 Jimmy Page special. One must be reasonable here.)
Let the person who’s going to be learning talk with the folks working at the music store, or your friend, to find the instrument that best fits them, be it acoustic or electric. Yes, there’s an “acoustic first” tradition, but that’s just a tradition, not a rule. I wanted to learn on an electric first, and now I have an acoustic too. A very nice little Ovation. I’m quite happy with it. The point is, you can learn on either, let the student have some say in this. Then, when they pick it out, buy it for them. Trust me, the gift will not lose any points in their eyes because it wasn’t a surprise, and down the road, the fact that you did it in a way that didn’t saddle them with something that sucks and made learning harder, will mean a lot to them.
While it’s true that it’s the artist, not the tools, the corollary to that is, you can’t be DaVinci with a ten – cent paint set. So avoid the cheap crap. Spend a little more, and get an instrument worth playing. My favorite resource? Musician’s Friend. Take a look on the site, and you’ll see you can get quality gear that won’t require a second mortgage. The person you’re buying the gear for will appreciate it.
Technorati Tags: Epiphone, Gibson, Guitar, Ibanez, Musical N00b, Musicians, Ovation, Learning to play
December 8th, 2006 at 4:25 pm
Hi! http://rik.tag-host.com/qgsffqgagbfqdfrbs/ christmas colonial decorating very merry christmas party christmas decorating light christmas costume santa suit matchbox christmas music box new york christmas cards cheap christmas easy gift christmas toy for kid christmas ebay vintage miniature christmas lights
October 17th, 2009 at 5:15 am
Hey, I just discovered this great site and thought it might be useful if you want to learn to play guitar. I know this is just one among lots of sites to learn guitar online, but hey, this looks very interesting and serious at least!
http://www.jamoramaguitar.net/
kind regards!
Robert
July 15th, 2011 at 2:05 am
Thanks a lot for your time to have had these things together on this website. Josh and that i very much valued your knowledge through your articles with certain things. I’m sure that you have numerous demands on your own schedule hence the fact that you took as much time as you did to steer people like us by this article is definitely highly liked.
August 29th, 2011 at 6:43 pm
Excellent job on this article. I am totally impressed. This information has brought forth more brain power than I’ve used in some time. Thank you for writing this great article.
August 31st, 2011 at 6:48 pm
I know there’s more to writing informational articles like this than typing some words. I get that you did a lot of work on this content. I think it’s impressive.
August 31st, 2011 at 6:51 pm
I really like how you write. You have a winning informational article here. I’m hoping you will add more articles on this subject so I can keep up with you.
August 31st, 2011 at 6:53 pm
I’ve noticed articles on this subject before, but never really paid attention to any of them. What caught my eye on this one was the use of many ideas to form one very strong conclusion!
September 15th, 2011 at 9:22 pm
I began reading this informative article and couldn’t quit. You are wonderful with words and your views are presented in an interesting and compelling manner. I’m glad I read this.
September 15th, 2011 at 9:25 pm
I have the many of the same thoughts contained in this article. It’s good to know I’m not the only person who has these views. You have written an excellent quality informational article. Thank you.
September 15th, 2011 at 9:27 pm
I got what you intend, regards for posting .Woh I am lucky to find this website through google.
September 15th, 2011 at 9:28 pm
I can appreciate great writing when I read it. This is truly great writing. You make valid and interesting points that you have presented in a unique way. This is an excellent high quality article.
September 15th, 2011 at 9:32 pm
I very much enjoyed reading your article. I know you put a lot of work into this and that deserves recognition. Very high quality article.
September 15th, 2011 at 9:33 pm
I Like your Blog Post. Do you have more Articles Like These in your Blog
September 15th, 2011 at 9:37 pm
This article is easy to follow and yet it really strikes a chord. It makes you stop and consider the viewpoints. You’ve done very well.
September 15th, 2011 at 9:45 pm
This is a great article with well-scripted, engaging content that is full of original and sensible views. Much of your informative content is in line with my way of thinking.
September 15th, 2011 at 9:46 pm
Reading this persuaded into the writer’s point of view. In-depth study has gone into what the writer has tried to get across, and it shows.